Knowledge, Attitude and Practice Study about the Disease of Women
Suffering From RTI/STI
Yogita Hiwarkar1* and Amit Hiwarkar2
1Dept.
of Community Medicine, Dr. Ulhas Patil
Medical College and Hospital, Jalgaon Kh. (M.S.), India
2Dept. of
Anaesthesiology, Dr. Ulhas Patil Medical College and Hospital, Jalgaon
Kh. (M.S.), India
ABSTRACT:
Background: Women are poorly informed about behaviours and conditions that influence reproductive
morbidity, symptoms of morbidity, the fact that symptoms can be treated and
where they can be treated. This is compounded by the "culture of
silence" that surrounds women.
Objective: To assess the knowledge, attitude and
practice about the disease of women suffering from RTI/STIs
Material and
methods: A cross
sectional house to house study was conducted. Data collection was done using
preformed pretested questionnaire. One hundred and thirty three and ninety women suffering from RTI/STI from
urban slums and rural area were included in the study.
Results:In both urban and rural area, more than half of the participants
were not aware about the cause of their symptoms. In urban area, half of the
participants feel that RTI/STI is curable while only one forth of rural
participants feel so. 45.8% women in urban and 60% women in rural area did not
seek treatment at all.
KEYWORDS: Knowledge, attitude and
practice, RTI/STIs, treatment seeking behavior
INTRODUCTION:
RTIs, particularly those
transmitted sexually, have different social meanings for women and men. Having
an STI is socially stigmatizing for women, far more so than for men is most
settings. Even such symptoms as discharge, incontinence and intermenstrual
bleeding can be a cause for shame and embarrassment. A range of factors inhibits appropriate health seeking behavior.
A fundamental barrier is the asymptomatic nature of many infections. The
symptoms of reproductive morbidities are either not considered serious, are
considered self-limiting or simply a normal consequence of marriage and
childbearing, and for all these reasons not severe enough to warrant attention.
Thus, even when women recognize a symptom to be abnormal and causing
discomfort, they often do not seek treatment readily.
Another hurdle to seeking
appropriate treatment is the "culture of silence" that surrounds
women's lives. Studies have shown that women consider any morbidity relating to
the reproductive system a matter of shame, and may not even discuss it within
the family, let alone seek care for it. A significant reason for preferring traditional
providers and chemists is women's reluctance to undergo a clinical examination
and associated social stigma. Confidentiality, or the fear of violation of
confidentiality, is another major threat to health-seeking in some settings,
particularly among adolescent girls. The authors have under taken this study
with the objective to assess the knowledge, attitude and practice about the
disease of women suffering from RTI/STI.
MATERIAL AND METHOD:
One hundred and thirty three and ninety
women suffering from RTI/STI of urban and rural area respectively were taken as
sample. The study was conducted in an urban slum and in the field practice area
of rural health training centre of Seth G.S.Medical
College, Mumbai-12 between September 2007 and November 2009. All sampled women
were married and in reproductive age group. Prior consent from each sampled
patient was taken. The data was collected in a predawn and pretested proforma.
For testing knowledge the questions about cause
of disease, curability of disease were asked, for testing attitude and
practices questions about person with whom information regarding reproductive
health related problem was shareed, treatment sought
or not were asked.
Treatment seeking behavior is defined as
part of several" illness or health seeking behavior" of women to
manage their symptoms associated with reproductive morbidity. Information about
treatment seeking behavior, place of the previous treatment sought and if
treatment was not sought then the reasons behind that were asked in detail.
Whenever available, the records of, the treatment taken or the investigations
done were seen.
OBSERVATIONS AND DISCUSSION:
On analysis of the collected data it was observed
that in urban area, 72 (54.13%) women said that they are unaware about the
cause of symptoms, 39 (29.32%) doesn’t think that it is an infection, 51
(38.3%) feel that it is due to CuT insertion and 11
(8.27%) feel that it is the effect of weakness. While in rural area, 60 (54%)
women said that they are unaware about the cause of symptoms, 25(27.7%) feel
that it is due to tubectomy or Cut insertion, 18
(20%) doesn’t think that it is an infection, 8 (8.88%) feel that it is due to
supernatural power or curse of the God and 13 (14.14%) feel that it is the
effect of weakness (Table-I).
TABLE-I: Perception of the cause of symptoms of RTI/STIs in study
participants
|
Perception of the cause of symptom |
URBAN |
RURAL |
||
|
n=133 |
%* |
n=90 |
%* |
|
|
Doesn’t
think that it is an infection |
39 |
29.32 |
18 |
20 |
|
CuT insertion/ Tubectomy operation |
51 |
38.34 |
25 |
27.77 |
|
Transmitted
from husband |
7 |
5.26 |
2 |
2.22 |
|
Sexual
relationship with many persons |
6 |
4.51 |
1 |
1.11 |
|
Effect
of weakness |
11 |
8.27 |
13 |
14.14 |
|
Melting
of bones |
2 |
1.5 |
3 |
3.33 |
|
Dietary
factors |
4 |
3 |
7 |
7.77 |
|
Stress |
3 |
2.25 |
0 |
0 |
|
Not
maintaining hygiene |
5 |
3.75 |
0 |
0 |
|
Supernatural
power/Curse of God |
2 |
1.5 |
8 |
8.88 |
|
Don’t
know |
72 |
54.13 |
54 |
60 |
*Since participants gave multiple responses
the total percentage would add up to more than 100.
In urban area, 100(45.45%) women feel
that RTI/STI is curable 32 (14.55%) feel
that it is not and others said they don’t have any knowledge about this whereas
in rural area, 37 (28.03%) feel that it is curable , 27(20.45%) feel that it is
not and others don’t know about curability of RTI/STI (Table-II; Figure-I).
TABLE-II: Awareness
about curability of RTI/STI in study subjects
|
STI curable |
URBAN |
RURAL |
||
|
Frequency |
Percent |
Frequency |
Percent |
|
|
Yes |
100 |
45.45 |
37 |
28.03 |
|
No |
32 |
14.55 |
27 |
20.45 |
|
Don’t
know |
88 |
40 |
68 |
51.52 |
|
Total |
220 |
100 |
132 |
100 |
FIGURE-I:
Awareness about curability of RTI/STI in study subjects
When asked about with whom they first
discussed the issue related to reproductive morbidity, in urban area out of 133
women who complained any symptom, 84 (63.15%) women said that they discussed
the issue with their husband while 34 (25.56%) women did not discuss the
problem with anyone. In rural area, 48 (53.33%) women did not discuss the
problem with anyone and 37 (41.1%) discussed it with their husband (Table-III;
Figure-II & III). (Table-IV; Figure-IV) revealed that in urban area, 61
(45.86%) women did not seek treatment at all, 35 (26.31%) went to government
hospital and 32 (24.06%) went to private hospital for treatment of reproductive
morbidity. In rural area, 54 (60%) women did not seek treatment at all, 19
(21.11%) went to government hospital and 15 (16.66%) went to private hospital
for treatment of reproductive morbidity. (Table-V) shows that the most common
reason for not seeking treatment in urban area was, 21(34.4%) women considered
the problem self-limiting. Other reasons were shyness 17(27.86%), fear of
internal examination 13(21.31%) and lack of female provider in the nearby
health facilities14 (22.9%).Similarly in rural area, the most common reason
was, 24 (44.4%) women considered the problem to be self-limiting. Other reasons
were no idea were to go 13 (24.07%), fear of internal
examination 11 (20.37%) and lack of female provider in the nearby health
facility (22.2%).
TABLE-III: Person
with whom information regarding reproductive health related problem was shared
|
Discussed the issue with |
URBAN |
RURAL |
||
|
n =133 |
% |
n =90 |
% |
|
|
None |
34 |
25.56 |
48 |
53.33 |
|
Husband |
84 |
63.15 |
37 |
41.11 |
|
Mother
in law or elderly women in family |
10 |
7.5 |
3 |
3.33 |
|
Friend
or neighbor |
5 |
3.75 |
2 |
2.22 |
|
Total |
133 |
100 |
90 |
100 |
TABLE- IV: Health
seeking behavior related to reproductive morbidity among study participants:
|
Treatment
sought from |
URBAN |
RURAL |
||
|
n = 133 |
% |
n = 90 |
% |
|
|
Treatment not sought |
61 |
45.86 |
54 |
60 |
|
Government hospital |
35 |
26.31 |
19 |
21.11 |
|
Private clinic |
32 |
24.06 |
15 |
16.66 |
|
Traditional medicine |
1 |
0.75 |
2 |
2.22 |
|
Medical shop |
4 |
3.0 |
0 |
0 |
|
Total |
133 |
100 |
90 |
100 |
TABLE-V: Reasons
for not seeking treatment in study subjects
|
Reasons for not seeking treatment |
URBAN |
RURAL |
||
|
n =61 |
%* |
n =54 |
%* |
|
|
Considered self limiting |
21 |
34.4 |
24 |
44.4 |
|
Shyness |
17 |
27.86 |
8 |
14.8 |
|
Indifference towards health |
10 |
16.39 |
8 |
14.81 |
|
No idea what to do |
7 |
11.47 |
13 |
24.07 |
|
Fear of internal examination |
13 |
21.31 |
11 |
20.37 |
|
Economic reasons |
3 |
4.91 |
8 |
14.8 |
|
Morning timing of OPD |
6 |
9.83 |
9 |
16.6 |
|
Lack of female doctor |
14 |
22.9 |
12 |
22.2 |
|
Home remedies |
4 |
6.5 |
7 |
12.96 |
* Since participants gave multiple
responses the total percentage would add up to more than 100.
FIGURE-II: Person with
whom information regarding reproductive health related problem was shared in
urban area
FIGURE-III: Person
with whom information regarding reproductive health related problem was shared
in rural area
FIGURE-IV: Health
seeking behaviour
Dr. G. Rangaiyan
et al (1) also got the similar perceptions about the etiology of symptoms in
their study. The various causes mentioned in their study were excess body heat
(40 per cent), witchcraft (37 per cent), abortion (not done properly) (35
percent), female sterilization (30 per cent), contraceptives (28 per cent),
childbirth (26 per cent), abortion (23 per cent), tension (10 per cent) and
promiscuity (6 per cent).
In study done by Alka
Sehgal et al (2), 40% of the women had no specific
perception of disease causation, while the rest related it to some abnormality.
Fifty percent of the women thought that no treatment was required for these
problems. 82% of women blamed the use of contraception directly or indirectly
for their disease(s). Very few women blamed supernatural powers for their
complaints. Menstrual problems and vaginal discharge are commonly associated
with food habits.
In study done by A J Singh (3), most of the
respondents ascribed vaginal discharge to weakness (kamjori),
melting of bones (haad galna)
and body heat (garmi). In study done by Rani
Bang et al (4), 80% of women had talked to someone else about their
gynecological problem, 76% of whom talked to their husbands. So, if men become
aware of reproductive health and women's suffering, they can persuade women to
seek health care. Comparable
results were found in the study done by Alka Sehgal (2), in which only 47.2% sought consultation for
gynecological diseases. The majority of women sought consultation from an
unqualified local practitioner or from a health care clinic.
Jasmin Helen Prasad et al(5) in their
study found that among symptomatic women, 65% had not sought any treatment for
their gynecologic problems. Of the 35% who had sought treatment, 21% of them
had opted for home remedies or traditional medicine, 57% had approached
unqualified private practitioners and 13% had gone to CHAD Hospital. Only 9%
had sought medical care at the government primary health centers.
While in study done by Dr. G. Rangaiyan et al (1) these figures
are quite less. In their study only 15 per cent of the women ever sought
treatment for one or more gynecological problems and the remaining, either took
some home remedies or did not seek any treatment at all. Jasmin
Helen Prasad et al (5). In their
study among symptomatic women, 65% had not sought any treatment for their
gynecologic problems. Of these women, 58% reported that they felt the symptom
was not alarming and so there was no need for treatment. Other less common
reasons were absence of a female provider in the nearby health care center,
lack of privacy and distance from home. The reasons given for not seeking care
were similar to those reported in other studies in India: stigma and
embarrassment, lack of privacy, lack of female doctors at health facilities and
treatment cost.
Parikh
et al (6) mentioned cost of treatment and male physician were main deterrents
for not seeking treatment. Dr. G. Rangaiyan et
al(1)mentioned the important reason for not seeking the treatment was the women
ignored gynecological symptoms and accepted them as a part of their general
ill-health and reproductive life. Other reasons generally cited for not seeking
any treatment were shyness and Husband or in-laws do not like them to go for
treatment. A J Singh et al (3) mentioned reasons for
non-consultation were - took it as normal (12), shyness (2), cost (2), no cure
(2) or others (11- no escort, can tolerate, do not know where to go etc).
The findings of the various studies
conducted by various researchers were more or less similar to the findings of
the present study.
CONCLUSION:
From above observations and
discussion the authors reached to the conclusion that women tend to consider
many symptoms as normal and do not seek treatment until discomfort is quite
high and so apparently remain infected for a long time. Other reasons for not
seeking treatment were shyness, fear of internal examination and lack of female
provider in the nearby health facilities. Copper T insertion, weakness, body
heat, melting of bones, sexual promiscuity, poor hygiene and diet were told as
the major causes of vaginal discharge. Most of the women feel shy
to discuss this problem with someone, so many a times they don’t tell about it
to anyone. Most of them discussed their problem with their husband or elderly
women in family. Most of the women in urban area first go to private clinic and
if no relief then they go to government hospital. A Flow-Chart, has been developed which may
be used as road map, ,which shows that by incorporating the gift of modern
technology judiciously i.e. audiovisuals aids etc. (Bansal
A.K.et al (9) and Garg Narendra
K. et al (10)), community (women) may be motivated to adopt healthy life style
by improving the utilization of health facilities and planning as per flow
chart and thus can save billions of rupees of the nation in terms of man day's
lost due to illness and expenses incurred on treatment.
REFERENCES:
1.
Dr. G. Rangaiyan
and Dr. S. Sureender. Women's perceptions of gynecological morbidity in South India: causes and remedies in a cultural context, journal of family welfare, Vol.46, No. 1, April
2000, 31-38.
2.
Alka Sehgal, Amarjeet Singh, Rajesh
Kumar et al. Selection of Essays: An Epidemiological Study of Gynecological
Morbidity in a Rural Community of Haryana, India.
http://www.idrc.ca/en/ev-28397-201-1-DO_TOPIC.html
3.
AJ Singh (2007) conducted a study on
Vaginal discharge: Its causes and associated symptoms as perceived by rural
north Indian women. Indian journal of Community Medicine, Vol.32, issue 1, pg
22-26.
4.
Bang R, lancet 1989, 85-7, A community
study of gynecological disease in Indian villages: some experiences and
reflections. POPLINE Document Number:
113353.
5. Jasmin Helen Prasad, Sulochana
Abraham, Kathleen M. Kurz et al, Reproductive Tract
Infections Among Young Married Women in Tamil Nadu, India, International Family Planning Perspectives,
Volume 31, Number 2, June 2005
6.
Parikh, I., Taskar,
V., Dharap, N., et al. (Undated): ‘Gynecological
Morbidity among Woman in a Bombay Slum’s, Draft Report, Streehitakarini, Bombay
7.
Bansal AK and Garg Narendra K; Information, education and communication in
context of reproductive and child health including HIV/AIDS : J.of Ravishankar University
:Vol.14 'N.B(Science)2001;pp 28-34.
8.
Garg Narendra K and Bansal AK Management of information system in context of
health care delvery: J.of Ravishankar University: Vol.14 'N.B(Science)2001;pp 35-40
Received on 13.02.2013
Modified on 20.02.2013
Accepted on 27.02.2013
© A&V Publication all right
reserved
Research J. Pharmacology and
Pharmacodynamics. 5(1): January –February 2013, 69-74